“Hidden Hiring” Trips Up Economists

The Daily Shot: 08-Jun-20
The United States
Canada
The Eurozone
Japan
China
Emerging Markets
Commodities
Energy
Equities
Credit
Rates
Food for Thought



 

The United States

1. Let’s begin with the May employment report, which was far stronger than the consensus estimate.

 
The gap between the forecast and the actual payrolls reported by the Labor Department was the largest on record (a 10 million gap).
 
Source: MarketWatch   Read full article  
Source: Bloomberg
 
While there are numerous theories as to why economists were so far off, one explanation was widely discussed on Friday. The jobless claims data and the ADP private payrolls report did not pick up what analysts call “hidden hiring.” Firms put their employees on “government payroll” for a couple of months with full intentions of bringing them back. Here is a summary from Ian Shepherdson, Pantheon Macroeconomics.
 
Source: Ian Shepherdson, Pantheon Macroeconomics  
 
This gradual rehiring can be seen in the Homebase small business data.
 
Source: Homebase  
 
Of course, assessing the employment situation in this environment can be hellish (see story).

——————–

 
Let’s take a look at the labor force flows data.
 
Here is the rehiring wave.
 
Flows from “unemployed” to “employed”:
 

 
“Not in labor force” to “employed” (these folks either didn’t qualify for unemployment benefits or their claims were delayed):
 

 
Layoffs have slowed.
 
“Employed” to “unemployed”:
 

 
“Employed” to “not in labor force:”
 

 
At the same time, flows from “unemployed” to “not in labor force” hit a record high.
 

 
Here are the workers that were classified as “not in the labor force” but are now counted as unemployed (probably due to the massive backlog in unemployment applications).
 

 
It will be a while before economists can fully make sense of the current labor market dynamics, and research papers will be written on this for years to come.

——————–

 
Next, we have a number of other results from the jobs report.
 
Underemployment (U-6)
 

 
Not in the labor force but want a job:
 
Source: Deutsche Bank Research  
 
The employment-to-population ratio:
 
Source: @WSJ   Read full article  
 
The employment diffusion index:
 
Source: Yardeni Research  
 
Reasons for unemployment:
 
Source: Morgan Stanley Research  
 
Job gains/losses by sector (3 charts):
 
Source: Oxford Economics   Read full article  
Source: @WSJ   Read full article  
Source: @bbgvisualdata   Read full article  
 
We’ll have more data on the labor market tomorrow.

——————–

 
2. The Citi Economic Surprise index spiked as a result of the jobs report.
 

 
3. Below are some updates on inflation.
 
Nomura expects another core CPI decline in May.
 
Source: Nomura Securities  
 
Food CPI probably rose sharply.
 
Source: Nomura Securities  
 
Market-based inflation expectations are recovering.
 
Source: Bloomberg

——————–

 
4. Consumer credit collapsed in April, driven by credit cards (revolving credit).
 

Source: Oxford Economics  

——————–

 
5. Economic policy uncertainty remains highly elevated.
 
Source: Danske Bank  


Back to Index

 

Canada

1. Similar to the US, “hidden hiring” surprised forecasters. Almost 300k jobs were added on a net basis, while the market expected a half a million loss.
 

 
The unemployment rate rose less than expected but still hit the highest level in recent history.
 
Source: Oxford Economics   Read full article  
 
This chart shows the number of workers who are employed but haven’t worked in May.
 
Source: Scotiabank Economics  

——————–

 
2. Business activity started stabilizing in May.
 

 
3. Canada’s trade tumbled in April.
 
Source: Economics and Strategy Group, National Bank of Canada  
 
4. The loonie rebound continues.
 


Back to Index

 

The Eurozone

1. Germany’s factory orders, industrial production crashed in April.
 


 
This chart shows the components of factory orders.
 
Source: Goldman Sachs  
 
But industrial activity started picking up from extreme lows in May.
 
Source: Pantheon Macroeconomics  

——————–

 
2. Spain’s industrial production also registered the worst decline in recent history (data through April).
 

 
3. This chart shows the year-over-year changes in Italian retail sales (data through April).
 

 
4. Below is the breakdown of the ECB’s QE purchases in the public and private sectors.
 
Source: Barclays Research  
 
Private sector PEPP purchases have focused on commercial paper, especially in the primary market.
 
Source: Barclays Research  
 
This chart from Gavekal shows potential ECB bond purchases relative to each nation’s projected budget deficit.
 
Source: Gavekal   


Back to Index

 

Japan

1. Household spending tumbled in April.
 

 
2. With companies raising cash, loan growth jumped in May.
 

 
3. Japan’s births continue to slow.
 
Source: @WSJ   Read full article  


Back to Index

 

China

1. The yield curve has been flattening.
 

 
2. China’s trade surplus jumped, as imports weakened (2nd chart).
 
Source: @markets   Read full article  
Source: @TeddyVallee  
 
On a year-to-date basis, China’s trade surplus is roughly at 2015 levels.
 


Back to Index

 

Emerging Markets

1. The rebound in EM currencies continues as risk appetite returns
 
The Thai baht:
 

 
The South African rand:
 

 
The Brezilian real:
 

 
The MSCI EM Currency Index:
 

——————–

 
2. Mexico’s CapEx was already tumbling in March.
 

 
May vehicle exports were almost nonexistent.
 

——————–

 
3. Brazil’s vehicle sales remain near multi-year lows.
 

 
4. Hungarian industrial output plummetted in April.
 
Source: ING  


Back to Index

 

Commodities

1. Iron ore prices are soaring.
 

 
2. Copper is still deeply oversold, according to BCA Research.
 
Source: BCA Research  
 
3. Speculative bets on gold are moderating.
 

 
4. US meat prices are declining from the recent highs, as production picks up (2nd chart).
 
Source: @WSJ   Read full article  
Source: @WSJ   Read full article  


Back to Index

 

Energy

1. The July NYMEX crude oil futures contract is near $40/bbl.
 

 
2. The US rig count is approaching 200 for the first time since 2009.
 

 
3. US refinery inputs are gradually recovering.
 
Source: Princeton Energy Advisors  
 
4. While gasoline demand has been improving, the total product supplied has weakened again.
 
Source: Princeton Energy Advisors  
 
5. Oil prices are catching up with energy shares.
 
h/t Namitha Jagadeesh   


Back to Index

 

Equities

1. Friday was a good day for beaten-down stocks.
 
Large-cap value:
 

 
Small caps:
 

 
Small-cap value:
 

 
On the other hand, momentum shares underperformed (2 charts).
 
Source: @markets   Read full article  

 
Here are a couple of other equity factor charts.
 
High-dividend stocks (boosted by energy):
 

 
High-beta:
 

——————–

 
2. The cyclicals/defensives ratio is back at multi-year highs.
 

 
3. The market continues to ignore the 1yr forward P/E ratios, as investors bet on a V-shaped recovery (S&P 600 = small caps, S&P 400 = mid-caps).
 
Source: Yardeni Research  
 
This chart shows the forward P/E ratio for equity markets around the world.
 
Source: Yardeni Research  

——————–

 
4. The US recent outperformance vs. other developed markets has been remarkable.
 
Source: BofA Merrill Lynch Global Research  
Source: Yardeni Research  

——————–

 
5. Outperforming 1929?
 
Source: @Schuldensuehner   Further reading  
 
6. The put/call ratio is near multi-year lows.
 


Back to Index

 

Credit

Inflows into corporate credit funds have been robust.
 
Investment-grade:
 
Source: BofA Merrill Lynch Global Research  
Source: Deutsche Bank Research  
 
High-yield:
 
Source: Goldman Sachs  


Back to Index

 

Rates

1. The Treasury curve has been steepening.
 

 
2. The copper-to-gold ratio points to higher bond yields.
 
Source: @RichardDias_CFA, @ISABELNET_SA  
 
3. Gross residential MBS issuance spiked amid a wave of refinancing and robust home-purchase applications.
 
Source: Morgan Stanley Research  


Back to Index

 

Food for Thought

1. The price of plastics:
 
Source: @financialtimes   Read full article  
 
2. CO2 declines by sector:
 
Source: @business   Read full article  
 
3. Is the coronavirus situation getting better?
 
Source: Gallup   Read full article  
 
4. Is the US economy in recession?
 
Source: Gallup   Read full article  
 
5. Voting by mail:
 
Source: Statista  
 
6. Police shootings:
 
Source: The Washington Post   Read full article  
 
7. Projections for the automobile market:
 
Source: @business   Read full article  
 
8. Preferences for streaming services:
 
Source: J.D. Power, @technology   Read full article  
 
9. Spending on luxury goods by region:
 
Source: @WSJ   Read full article  

——————–


Back to Index